The economist who changed the question from “which security?” to “which portfolio?”
University of Chicago, early 1950s
Economics was changing.
Mathematics and statistics were beginning to reshape the way economists thought about markets and investment.
At the University of Chicago, Harry Markowitz studied economics alongside people such as Milton Friedman, Jacob Marschak, and Leonard Savage.
As a young economist, he became associated with the Cowles Commission for Research in Economics, an important center for mathematical economics and econometrics.
It was an unusual intellectual environment.
Economists were trying to turn economic ideas into something that could be measured, modeled, and tested.
And somewhere in this world, Markowitz was thinking about a very ordinary question.
Markowitz would eventually become one of the most important figures in modern portfolio theory.
But the idea didn't begin with a complicated formula.
One influence on Markowitz's thinking was John Burr Williams' The Theory of Investment Value.
Williams had approached the problem of valuing a stock through its future dividends.
The basic idea was:
It was a way of thinking about an individual security.
But Markowitz noticed something.
An investor doesn't usually own just one security.
They own several.
A portfolio.
From the stock to the portfolio
Imagine you have two stocks.
Which one would you choose?
Most people would choose A.
And why wouldn't you? 10% is better than 8%.
But there's a problem.
Look again
Suppose these are the annual returns:
| Year | Stock A | Stock B |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | +20% | +8% |
| 2 | 0% | +10% |
| 3 | +10% | +6% |
The average return of A is: 10%. The average return of B is: 8%. So A still wins.
But look at the journey.
A's returns move around much more.
So now we have another question:
This gives us two things to measure.
How much do we expect to earn?
How much do those returns vary?
Now we have a better way to compare investments.
But Markowitz wasn't finished. Because he asked a more interesting question.
Why choose between A and B? What happens if you combine them?
Imagine you have ₹10,000. You could invest:
Each combination creates a different portfolio. And each portfolio has:
An expected return. A level of risk.
Now the question has changed. We are no longer asking:
“Which stock is better?”
We are asking:
Suppose A and B both have risk. Does that mean putting them together simply gives you the average of their risks?
No.
Because A and B don't necessarily move together.
Imagine A falls while B rises. The two movements can partially offset each other.
And that means something incredibly important:
That relationship is captured by:
Covariance
And, more intuitively:
Correlation
Now the math makes sense
For a two-stock portfolio:
That's the portfolio's expected return. But portfolio risk is:
The final term matters. Because it tells us how A and B move together.
And suddenly we can do something powerful.
Now imagine we don't create five portfolios.
We create hundreds. Or thousands.
Each one has: Expected return — and — Risk.
Plot every portfolio.
Some will be terrible. Some will be dominated by others. For example:
Why would you choose X? Portfolio Y gives you more return and less risk.
Now look at all those portfolios. There is a boundary.
A set of portfolios where you cannot get a higher expected return without accepting more risk. That boundary is the:
These are the portfolios that offer the highest expected return for each level of risk. Or: the lowest possible risk for each level of expected return.
And this is where Markowitz's contribution becomes clear.
He gave investors a framework for solving an optimization problem:
Given a level of risk, what combination of securities gives me the highest expected return?
Or: given a target return, what combination of securities gives me the lowest risk?
This became known as:
Expected return.
Risk.
How the securities move together.
Together, they allow us to think about the portfolio as a whole.
In 1952, Markowitz published “Portfolio Selection” in the Journal of Finance.
The contribution wasn't simply a new formula. It was a change in perspective.
The unit of analysis had changed.
And that became the foundation of Modern Portfolio Theory.
But the story wasn't over
Markowitz had shown us how to think about the best combinations of risky assets. But another question remained.
What happens when we introduce a risk-free asset?
Can an investor combine the optimal risky portfolio with something that has no—or effectively negligible—risk? And what happens to the efficient frontier then?
That takes us to the next chapter.